Appeal Court Reverses Murder Conviction After Jury Confusion Over Self-Defense Instructions
Appeal Court Reverses Murder Conviction After Jury Confusion Over Self-Defense Instructions When a person is convicted at trial, the fight for justice does not necessarily end. California law allows individuals to challenge convictions through appeals and writs when legal errors may have affected the outcome of their case. A recent decision in People v. Brim highlights how mistakes made during jury deliberations can result in a conviction being overturned. Our…
Read More
Court Rules Misdemeanor Case Must Be Dismissed When Jury Trial Did Not Begin Within 45 Days
Court Rules Misdemeanor Case Must Be Dismissed When Jury Trial Did Not Begin Within 45 Days If you are facing misdemeanor charges in California, you have an important constitutional and statutory right to a speedy trial. A recent California case, Nuanmanee v. Superior Court, reinforces that courts cannot delay your trial beyond the legal deadline simply because of scheduling policies or administrative convenience. Our experienced criminal defense attorneys at Wallin…
Read More
Racial Bias in the Jury Room Can Destroy a Fair Trial: Why a Conviction Was Reversed in U.S. v. Sanchez
Racial Bias in the Jury Room Can Destroy a Fair Trial: Why a Conviction Was Reversed in U.S. v. Sanchez One of the cornerstones of the American criminal justice system is the right to a fair trial before an impartial jury. Every accused individual, regardless of race, ethnicity, or background, is entitled to have his or her guilt or innocence determined solely on the evidence presented in court. Unfortunately, racial…
Read MoreWhen Jury Instructions Misstate the Law: Understanding "Force" in California Sex Offense Cases
When Jury Instructions Misstate the Law: Understanding "Force" in California Sex Offense Cases In criminal trials, jury instructions serve as the foundation for how jurors understand and apply the law. When these instructions are incorrect or misleading, it can result in a wrongful conviction. A recent California appellate decision shows how proper jury instructions are in sex offense cases, particularly regarding the legal definition of "force." Our experienced criminal defense…
Read MoreImproper "Kill Zone" Jury Instructions Could Result in Your Conviction Being Overturned
Improper "Kill Zone" Jury Instructions Could Result in Your Conviction Being Overturned In every criminal trial, one of the most critical yet often overlooked components is the set of instructions given to the jury. Before deliberation begins, the judge provides the jury with carefully worded instructions that explain the relevant laws, define legal terms, outline the elements of each charged offense, and describe how to properly evaluate evidence. These instructions…
Read More
IF YOU WANT TO WIN YOUR CASE YOUR LAWYER NEEDS TO KNOW HOW TO GET THE BEST EVIDENCE BEFORE THE JURY OR JUDGE
IF YOU WANT TO WIN YOUR CASE YOUR LAWYER NEEDS TO KNOW HOW TO GET THE BEST EVIDENCE BEFORE THE JURY OR JUDGE Improper Rehabilitation Improper rehabilitation of a witness occurs when efforts to restore the witness's credibility in court are mishandled or conducted in violation of legal standards. This can involve introducing inadmissible evidence, such as prior consistent statements that do not meet the exceptions outlined in California Evidence…
Read More
You Need A Criminal Lawyer Who Will Obtain All Of The Evidence The District Attorney Has Against You And Challenge That Evidence In Court
You Need A Criminal Lawyer Who Will Obtain All Of The Evidence The District Attorney Has Against You And Challenge That Evidence In Court Navigating the legal system can be daunting, especially for those who find themselves accused of a crime. At the heart of a robust defense lies one fundamental aspect—obtaining all evidence against you as soon as possible. This blog aims to shed light on the importance of…
Read MoreThe Jury and Not The Judge Will Decide What Your Sentence Will Be If You Are Convicted of Most Felonies - Penal Code Section 1170
The Jury and Not The Judge Will Decide What Your Sentence Will Be If You Are Convicted of Most Felonies - Penal Code Section 1170 One crucial aspect of felony cases is determining whether "aggravating factors" exist, which can significantly increase your prison sentence if convicted. Under California Penal Code Section 1170, it's not a judge but a jury that must decide on these aggravating factors. Let's explore how this…
Read More
“Harmless Errors” By the Court May Not Affect the Verdict
“Harmless Errors” By the Court May Not Affect the Verdict People v. Schultz (2020) Defendant Michael Schultz (“Schultz”) was convicted of first-degree murder of Cynthia Burger (Penal Code § 187(a)) by a jury, finding true the special circumstance allegations that the murder was committed while Schultz was engaged in the commission of rape and burglary (PC § 190.2(a)(17)(C),(G)). After the penalty phase trial, the jury returned a verdict sentencing Schultz…
Read MoreWhat is the Right to Waive a Jury Trial?
What is the Right to Waive a Jury Trial? In criminal prosecutions, the defendant may decide whether he or she would like to waive the right to a jury trial. Should the defendant choose to waive this right, the defendant will have what is called a bench trial that is conducted by a judge alone. Sometimes, the court may find a defendant incompetent to waive his or her right to…
Read More