Criminal Defense Blog
If you are facing serious criminal charges in California, or have already been convicted of multiple offenses arising from the same incident, the law may limit how many times you can be punished for the same criminal act. A recent case, People v. Thornton, highlights how Penal Code section 654 can protect accused individuals from receiving multiple punishments for crimes based on the same physical act and injury.
This case is especially important for people convicted of multiple driving-related offenses after a crash. Even when a person violates more than one law, the prosecution does not always have the right to impose separate sentences for every offense.
Our experienced criminal defense attorneys at Wallin & Klarich can guide you through the legal process. Call Wallin & Klarich today toll-free at (877) 466-5245 for your free consultation with one of our criminal defense attorneys near you.
Shaun Thornton was under the influence of drugs when he fled from police in his girlfriend’s car. During the pursuit, he ran traffic signals and eventually crashed into a tree. His girlfriend was trapped beneath the dashboard and suffered a fractured pelvis that required surgery and months of recovery.
A jury convicted Thornton of several offenses, including evading police while causing serious bodily injury and driving under the influence of drugs and causing injury. After an earlier appeal led to resentencing, the trial court imposed a sentence of 25 years to life for felony evasion, along with a concurrent four-year sentence for drug-impaired driving.
Thornton appealed again, arguing that California Penal Code section 654 prohibited the court from punishing him separately for both driving-related offenses because they arose from the same crash and injury.
The appellate court agreed with his argument regarding the sentence. It reversed the sentence and sent the case back to the trial court. The convictions otherwise remained in place.
Penal Code section 654 generally prohibits multiple punishment for a single act, even when that act violates more than one criminal law. The rule is intended to prevent the government from punishing someone twice for the same criminal conduct.
However, determining whether the law applies depends on the specific offenses and the facts of the case. When separate acts are involved, a court may need to consider the person’s intent and objectives. But when a single physical act completes multiple crimes, the analysis can be different.
In People v. Thornton, both driving-related offenses required proof that Thornton’s conduct caused bodily injury. Neither the act of fleeing police nor driving under the influence, standing alone, completed both offenses. Instead, both convictions depended on the crash that fractured his girlfriend’s pelvis. That was the only injury established at trial.
Because the same physical act caused the same injury to the same victim and completed both offenses, the court concluded that Thornton could not be punished separately for both crimes.
The trial court must now impose punishment for one of the two offenses and stay the sentence for the other. A stayed sentence does not erase the conviction; it prevents the sentence for that offense from being carried out while the stay remains in effect.
People v. Thornton demonstrates why it is important to examine every count in a criminal case, especially when several charges arise from one incident.
For example, if you are accused of fleeing police, driving under the influence, and causing an injury in a single crash, you may face multiple convictions. But that does not automatically mean the court can impose a separate punishment for every offense.
A criminal defense attorney can review whether multiple counts are based on the same physical act, whether the offenses require proof of the same injury, and whether Penal Code section 654 limits the sentences the court may impose.
The issue can be especially important when a person faces a lengthy prison sentence. A successful sentencing challenge may not eliminate the convictions, but it could prevent an additional sentence from being imposed or carried out unlawfully.
Whether section 654 applies depends on the facts of your case, the elements of the offenses, and the evidence supporting each conviction. The fact that two crimes happened during the same incident does not automatically mean the court must stay one sentence.
However, if the same physical act completed multiple offenses and caused the same injury, People v. Thornton may provide important support for a sentencing challenge.
If you have already been convicted or sentenced, an attorney can review your case to determine whether a direct appeal or another available legal procedure may allow you to challenge an unlawful sentence. Strict deadlines and procedural rules may apply, so it is important to seek legal advice promptly.
If you have been charged with multiple offenses arising from the same incident, or believe the court imposed multiple punishments for the same act, Wallin & Klarich may be able to help you understand your legal options.
At Wallin & Klarich, we have offices all over Southern California: Irvine, Pasadena, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, Torrance, and Anaheim. Additionally, our law firm can handle many types of cases statewide.
Discover how our team can assist you. Contact us today, toll-free at (877) 466-5245 for a free consultation with a skilled criminal defense attorney near you.

RELATED ARTICLES
Double-click this headline to edit the text.